When Revealed: Remove Carcharoth from play and put the Carcharoth deck aside. Add Carcharoth the Tormented to the staging area. Remove half of the damage on Carcharoth (rounding up).

When Revealed: Discard all Hunt locations from the victory display.

Forced: If an ally is destroyed by Carcharoth, place 1 damage on this stage. After the 4th damage is placed on this stage, reset the quest deck to stage 1A and follow the setup instructions again.

If Carcharoth the Tormented is destroyed, you have recovered the Silmaril and won the game.